| Register Now | |
| My Points | |
| My Games | |
| Page 2 of 2 (19 messages) | « First page... 1 2 |
That is . . . disappointing. The Rivers are barely playable, but with the possibility of using Flood Waters to pile on the triggered effects along with KotHH gave me a small glimmer of hope. I guess I'll just put them back in the binder . . . .
Thanks.
Ph'nglui mglw'nafh Cthulhu R'lyeh wgah'nagl fhtagn!
Somebody from our French board asked Damon stone who has answered the following :
"Yes, Floodwaters allows the chosen River plot to resolve its "then" effect."
However I completely agree with ktom and the previous Damon statement.
The main reason is that Flood Water 's "as if you had just revealed it." is only applicable to trigger the effect. And triggering the effect means step 4.1) Initiation. From Step 4.2), the effect is already considered to have been trigered/played. So the "as if" is no longer applicable when we arrive at step 4.3) Passive resolution. And that's when the "Then.." effect of Rover plot card kicks in. At that moment, the "as if…" from Flood Water no longer applies.
Bolzano
Bolzano said:
"Yes, Floodwaters allows the chosen River plot to resolve its "then" effect."
There is a fine line between 'hobby' and 'mental illness.'
 - Dave Berry
So, I have informed Nate about the contradictory Damon rulings and asked him to confirm the original ruling and he did.
Here is his email:
1) The effect is triggered "as if" the plot was just revealed, but it is not actually revealed
2) The event allows to trigger a River plot. According to AGOT Timing charts, triggering occurs in Step 1) Initiation. At Step 2), the event is considered to have been played/triggered even if cancelled (as per FAQ entry). So by its resolution in Step 3) we are no longer in the initiation/trigger phase when the River plot is "as if you had just revealed it". So now the "Then…" effect tries to initiate and fail.
Bolzano
| Page 2 of 2 (19 messages) | « First page... 1 2 |